חישובי ממס משתמע באמצעות Qiskit Serverless
הערכת שימוש: 2 דקות על מעבד Heron r2 (הערה: זו הערכה בלבד. זמן הריצה שלכם עשוי להשתנות.)
תוצאות למידה
-
כיצד להגדיר ולהריץ זרימת עבודה מרוחקת באמצעות Qiskit Serverless
-
כיצד לחשב אפקטים של ממס משתמע באמצעות מחשב קוונטי
דרישות קדם
רקע
חישובי ממס משתמע נמצאים בשימוש תדיר בביופיזיקה חישובית. מודלים אלה מתארים כיצד תרכובת מומסת מתקשרת עם ממס, מבלי לדגם ישירות את מערכת הממס. במקום זאת, נעשה קירוב שבו מודל מערכת המומס עטוף בייצוג מתמטי של תווך דיאלקטרי המאופיין באופן אמפירי. הקירוב הדיאלקטרי הזה מתקשר לאחר מכן עם המומס, אשר עצמו מודגם ישירות. התווך הדיאלקטרי משפיע על מאפייני מערכת המומס, כגון אנרגיית מצב היסוד שלה, על ידי אינטראקציה עם שדה האלקטרונים שלה. זה חשוב למודלים ביופיזיים שבהם נעשה שימוש, למשל, בגילוי תרופות, מכיוון שתרכובות מתנהגות אחרת בסביבות דיאלקטריות שונות. דיגום תרכובת באוויר (בוואקום) יתאר התנהגות שונה מדיגומה במים. מכיוון שתרכובות תרופתיות חייבות להיכנס לגוף האדם, המורכב בעצמו בעיקר ממים, מועיל לדגם תרכובת בתמיסה כמו מים במקום בוואקום. עם מודלי ממס משתמע, נוכל להשיג את ההתנהגות הזו בזול, אף על פי שהתוצאה הסופית בדרך כלל תהיה מקורבת יותר מהמקבילה: מודלי ממס מפורש יקרים יותר חישובית שיוצרים ייצוגים ישירים הן של המומס והן של הממס.
במדריך זה, אנחנו מדגימים כיצד ניתן לשלב אלגוריתם קוונטי, ליכסון קוונטי מבוסס-דגימה (SQD), במודל ממס משתמע זול יחסית מבחינה חישובית. בדוגמה, אנחנו מתארים כיצד מתיל-אמין מתנהג כאשר הוא נמס במים. אנחנו משווים את האלגוריתם הקוונטי לשיטת השוואה קלאסית מתקדמת הנקראת CASCI, ומראים התאמה קרובה בין החישובים האלה. אנחנו מציגים ארכיטקטורת מחשוב-על ממוקדת-קוונטים במיניאטורה, על ידי העברת העיבוד הקלאסי היקר חישובית שלאחר מכן של חלק הדגימה הקוונטית של השגרה לסביבה מבוססת-ענן בתוך Qiskit Serverless. הקוד גם מדגים הרצה מקבילית על פני ליבות CPU זמינות מרחוק כדי לשפר את זמן החישוב.
Qiskit Serverless היא מסגרת עבודה להרצת עומסי עבודה קוונטיים וקלאסיים מבוזרים ללא ניהול תשתית. אין הקצאת שרתים (אין הקמת EC2, אשכולות, מכולות Docker), אין כלי תזמור (Kubernetes, Docker Swarm) ואין ניטור/תחזוקה. כל job ב-Serverless רץ במכולה נקייה, מבצע את הקוד שלכם, ולאחר מכן נסגר. אין זיכרון בין jobs. אתם פשוט כותבים את הקוד שלכם ולאחר מכן שולחים את ה-job. בתוך job ב-Serverless, תוכנית יכולה לגשת בצורה חלקה ל-Backend-ים של IBM Quantum® ולעבד תוצאות באופן קלאסי שם. עם Qiskit Serverless, משתמשים יכולים לגשת לליבות CPU וזיכרון מרוחקים שתמיד פעילים, המספקים חלוקה של עומסי עבודה קלאסיים מסוימים על פני משאבים מרוחקים. משתמשים גם מרוויחים יתרון מסוים בעיבוד מקבילי של תוכניות תוך הימנעות מכאבי ראש נפוצים מכיבוי מכשירים באמצע ההרצה. למידע נוסף על Qiskit Serverless, ראו את התיעוד שלה, וכן חומר נוסף בGitHub.
מדריך זה מציג יישום רלוונטי של הבאים:
-
ליכסון קוונטי מבוסס-דגימה
-
מודלים חישוביים לקוח-שרת עבור מחשוב קוונטי
מדריך זה נכתב בהשראת מחקר שנערך במרפאת קליבלנד (Cleveland Clinic) ומבוסס עליו, כפי שמתואר ב-Kaliakin, Danil, et al. "Implicit solvent sample-based quantum diagonalization." The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 129.23 (2025): 5788-5796, וחושף את זרימת העבודה המלאה לחישובי ממס משתמע (implicit solvent), תוך הרחבתה בעזרת עקביות עצמית איטרטיבית של הממס ("The Heartwood Algorithm", M. Motta, T. Pellegrini, 2025), אופטימיזציית גיאומטריה, ובחירה אוטומטית של פריסת Qubit. עיין בתבנית Qiskit Function של SQD IEF-PCM, שפותחה במשותף על ידי מרפאת קליבלנד ו-IBM® בהתבסס על מחקר מרפאת קליבלנד, לצורך ממשק פשוט וממוקד-קופסה-שחורה להרצת חישובי ממס משתמע.
דרישות
לפני שתתחיל במדריך זה, ודא שהתקנת את הרכיבים הבאים:
- Qiskit SDK גרסה 2.0 ואילך עם תמיכת visualization
- Qiskit Runtime גרסה 0.40 ואילך (
pip install qiskit-ibm-runtime) - Qiskit IBM Catalog
pip install qiskit_ibm_catalog - Qiskit IBM Serverless
pip install qiskit_serverless - תוסף Qiskit: ליכסון קוונטי מבוסס-דגימה (SQD) גרסה 0.12.0
pip install qiskit_addon_sqd - PySCF
pip install pyscf - FFSIM
pip install ffsim - Matplotlib
pip install matplotlib - Geometric
pip install geometric
הגדרה
# Added by doQumentation — required packages for this notebook
!pip install -q ffsim matplotlib numpy psutil pyscf qiskit qiskit-addon-sqd qiskit-ibm-catalog qiskit-ibm-runtime qiskit-serverless rustworkx
# Establish Quantum Resource connection
from qiskit_ibm_runtime import QiskitRuntimeService
service = QiskitRuntimeService()
backend = service.least_busy()
print(f"Using backend {backend.name}")
# Establish Classical HPC Resource connection
from qiskit_ibm_catalog import QiskitFunction, QiskitServerless
client = QiskitServerless()
צור תיקייה בדיוק לצד תוכנית המחברת (notebook) הראשית בשם source_files. תשים בתיקייה זו קבצי Python שברצונך לשתף עם סביבת החישוב המרוחקת. עליך ליצור שני קבצים:
-
source_files\diagonalization_engine.py -
source_files\classical_simulation.py
לחץ כדי להרחיב את הטקסט של כל סקריפט למטה, ולאחר מכן העתק והדבק את התוכן לקובץ מקומי עם שמות הנתיבים הללו.
לחץ כדי להציג את source_files\diagonalization_engine.py
לחץ כדי להציג את source_files\classical_simulation.py
הערה
למידע נוסף, ראו את מדריך תבנית פונקציית Qiskit של SQD IEF-PCM (שפותח במשותף על ידי Cleveland Clinic ו-IBM) שאוזכר למעלה. ראו גם את הספרייה qiskit_addon_sqd.
#!/usr/bin/env python3
import numpy as np
from json.encoder import JSONEncoder
from json.decoder import JSONDecoder
from functools import partial
import os
from qiskit_serverless import (
distribute_task,
get_arguments,
get,
save_result,
get_runtime_service,
)
from qiskit_addon_sqd.fermion import (
SCIResult,
diagonalize_fermionic_hamiltonian,
solve_sci,
)
### Argument retrieval
args = get_arguments()
data = args["data"] # Chemistry Data
energy_tol = args["energy_tol"] # SQD option
occupancies_tol = args["occupancies_tol"] # SQD option
max_iterations = args["max_iterations"] # SQD option
symmetrize_spin = args["symmetrize_spin"] # Eigenstate solver option
carryover_threshold = args["carryover_threshold"] # Eigenstate solver option
num_batches = args["num_batches"] # Eigenstate solver option
samples_per_batch = args["samples_per_batch"] # Eigenstate solver option
max_cycle = args["max_cycle"] # Eigenstate solver option
mem = args["mem"] # Memory per Worker
# --- fan‑out target: 1 CPU + mem GB RAM per call -------------
@distribute_task(target={"cpu": 1, "mem": mem * 1024**3})
def _solve_sci_worker(
ix, ci_strs, one_body_tensor, two_body_tensor, norb, nelec, spin_sq
):
print(f">>>>> WORKER {ix} INITIATED")
res = solve_sci(
ci_strs,
one_body_tensor,
two_body_tensor,
norb=norb,
nelec=nelec,
spin_sq=spin_sq,
)
print(f">>>>> WORKER {ix} COMPLETE")
return res
def distribute_solve_sci_batch(
ci_strings: list[tuple[np.ndarray, np.ndarray]],
one_body_tensor: np.ndarray,
two_body_tensor: np.ndarray,
norb: int,
nelec: tuple[int, int],
*,
spin_sq: float | None = None,
**kwargs,
) -> list[SCIResult]:
"""Diagonalize Hamiltonian in subspaces, parallelizing across
vCPUs in the Serverless environment.
Args:
ci_strings: List of pairs (strings_a, strings_b) of arrays of
spin-alpha CI strings and spin-beta CI strings whose Cartesian
product gives the basis of the subspace in which to perform a
diagonalization.
one_body_tensor: The one-body tensor of the Hamiltonian.
two_body_tensor: The two-body tensor of the Hamiltonian.
norb: The number of spatial orbitals.
nelec: The numbers of alpha and beta electrons.
spin_sq: Target value for the total spin squared for the ground state.
If ``None``, no spin will be imposed.
**kwargs: Keyword arguments to pass to
`pyscf.fci.selected_ci.kernel_fixed_space`
(https://pyscf.org/pyscf_api_docs/pyscf.fci.html#pyscf.fci.selected_ci.kernel_fixed_space
Returns:
The results of the diagonalizations in the subspaces given by ci_strings.
"""
inputs = [
(ix, ci_strs, one_body_tensor, two_body_tensor, norb, nelec, spin_sq)
for ix, ci_strs in enumerate(ci_strings)
]
# fan‑out: spawn one worker per input tuple
print(">>>>> ENTERING WORKER FAN-OUT")
refs = [_solve_sci_worker(*input_) for input_ in inputs]
print(">>>>> WAITING ON WORKERS TO FINISH TASKS")
# fan‑in: block until every worker finishes
results = get(refs)
print(">>>>> DISTRIBUTED JOBS COMPLETED")
return results
# A caveat of executing a Python program remotely is
# that the inputs to the remote program must be passed
# over an internet network. Similarly, the outputs
# must be passed back to the local program via the same
# structure. Python objects are not always able to be
# passed over a network, and must be encoded in a
# JSON serializable format.
i_data = JSONDecoder().decode(data)
# i_data has all of the information needed from the
# local program to pick up where the computation left off
# after its submission to the remote environment.
[
job_id,
hcore,
eri,
num_orbitals,
nuclear_repulsion_energy,
num_elec_a,
num_elec_b,
] = i_data
# Re-convert data back into numpy format, after serialization
hcore = np.array(hcore)
eri = np.array(eri)
nuclear_repulsion_energy = np.float64(nuclear_repulsion_energy)
# Instantiate Runtime Service to retrieve the
# bitstrings from the QPU job. We provided these
# credentials upon Serverless setup.
service = get_runtime_service()
# retrieving the QPU job data from the Serverless side
job = service.job(job_id)
primitive_result = job.result()
pub_result = primitive_result[0]
bit_array = pub_result.data.meas # Getting the bitstrings
# Pass options to the built-in eigensolver
sci_solver = partial(
distribute_solve_sci_batch, spin_sq=0.0, max_cycle=max_cycle
)
# List to capture intermediate results
result_history = []
def callback(results: list[SCIResult]):
result_history.append(results)
iteration = len(result_history)
print(f">>>>> SQD ITERATION {iteration}")
for i, result in enumerate(results):
print(f">>>>> SUBSAMPLE {i}")
print(f">>>>> \tENERGY: {result.energy + nuclear_repulsion_energy}")
print(
f">>>>> \tSUBSPACE DIMENSION: {np.prod(result.sci_state.amplitudes.shape)}"
)
result = diagonalize_fermionic_hamiltonian(
hcore,
eri,
bit_array,
samples_per_batch=samples_per_batch,
norb=num_orbitals,
nelec=(num_elec_a, num_elec_b),
num_batches=num_batches,
energy_tol=energy_tol,
occupancies_tol=occupancies_tol,
max_iterations=max_iterations,
sci_solver=sci_solver,
symmetrize_spin=symmetrize_spin,
carryover_threshold=carryover_threshold,
callback=callback,
seed=12345,
)
print(">>>>> EXACT DIAGONALIZATION COMPLETE. CLEANING UP, SERIALIZING DATA.")
# Numpy arrays are not JSON serializable.
# Convert them to List objects before using the JSONEncoder
o_data = JSONEncoder().encode(
[
result.energy + nuclear_repulsion_energy,
result.energy,
result.rdm1.tolist(),
result.rdm2.tolist(),
[x.tolist() for x in result.orbital_occupancies],
[
result.sci_state.nelec,
result.sci_state.norb,
[x.tolist() for x in result.sci_state.orbital_occupancies()],
[x.tolist() for x in result.sci_state.rdm()],
],
]
)
# JSON-safe package
save_result({"outputs": o_data}) # single JSON blob returned to client
#!/usr/bin/env python3
from json.encoder import JSONEncoder
from json.decoder import JSONDecoder
from qiskit_serverless import get_arguments, save_result
import pyscf
from pyscf import gto, scf
from pyscf.solvent import pcm
from pyscf.mcscf import avas
import psutil
mem_info = (
psutil.virtual_memory()
) # Get information about virtual memory (RAM)
total_ram_gb = mem_info.total / (1024**3) # Convert bytes to GB
print(f">>>>> SERVERLESS TOTAL RAM: {total_ram_gb:.2f} GB")
### Argument retrieval
args = get_arguments()
data = args["data"] # Chemistry Data
i_data = JSONDecoder().decode(data)
[mol_geo, eps, ao_labels] = i_data
print(">>>>> DEFINING MOLECULE")
mol = gto.M()
mol.atom = mol_geo
mol.basis = "cc-pVDZ"
mol.unit = "Ang"
mol.charge = 0
mol.spin = 0
mol.verbose = 0
print(">>>>> BUILDING MOLECULE")
mol.build()
print(">>>>> DEFINING PCM")
cm = pcm.PCM(mol)
cm.eps = eps # for water
cm.method = "IEF-PCM"
print(">>>>> BUILDING RESTRICTED HARTREE FOCK")
mf = scf.RHF(mol).PCM(cm) # This is the Final SCF object
mf.kernel(verbose=0)
print(">>>>> RUNNING AVAS")
avas_ = avas.AVAS(mf, ao_labels, with_iao=True, canonicalize=True, verbose=0)
avas_.kernel()
norb, ne_act, mo_avas = avas_.ncas, avas_.nelecas, avas_.mo_coeff
print(">>>>> STARTING CASCI")
mc_pcm = pyscf.mcscf.CASCI(mf, norb, ne_act).PCM(
cm
) # Make sure to decorate the CASCI object with PCM
mc_pcm.mo_coeff = mo_avas
# mc_pcm.max_memory = 140000
(CASCI_E, _, _, _, _) = mc_pcm.kernel(verbose=0)
print(f">>>>> CASCI_E: {CASCI_E}")
o_data = JSONEncoder().encode([float(CASCI_E)])
# JSON-safe package
save_result({"outputs": o_data}) # single JSON blob returned to client
עלינו לשתף את התוכנית המיועדת לרוץ בסביבת הענן, ולהעלות אותה מחדש בכל פעם שאנחנו משנים את קוד המקור שלה:
client.upload(
QiskitFunction(
title="diagonalization_engine",
entrypoint="diagonalization_engine.py", # lives in ./source_files
working_dir="source_files",
)
)
client.upload(
QiskitFunction(
title="classical_simulation",
entrypoint="classical_simulation.py", # lives in ./source_files
working_dir="source_files",
)
)
דוגמת סימולטור בקנה מידה קטן
מדריך זה אינו עושה שימוש בסימולטור בקנה מידה קטן, מכיוון שהכוונה היא להדגים יישום קוונטי הניתן להרחבה (scalable) שחורג מתחום החקירה של סימולטורים. במקום זאת, נראה בהמשך כיצד ניתן ליישם שיטה זו באמצעות שיטת השוואה קלאסית מתקדמת הנקראת CASCI.
דוגמת חומרה בקנה מידה גדול
# This is a useful helper function that displays
# remote job execution details to the user's local machine
def feedback_serverless(serverless_job):
import time
# Wait for the job to execute
print(f">>>>> Serverless status: {serverless_job.job_id}")
timer = 0
while timer < 10000:
if (
serverless_job.status() == "QUEUED"
or serverless_job.status() == "INITIALIZING"
or serverless_job.status() == "RUNNING"
):
print(f">>>>> [{timer}s] Serverless job {serverless_job.job_id}: \
{serverless_job.status()}")
time.sleep(10)
timer += 10
elif serverless_job.status() == "ERROR":
print(
f">>>>> Serverless job {serverless_job.job_id}: {serverless_job.status()}"
)
print(">>>>> Logs:")
print(serverless_job.logs())
break
elif serverless_job.status() == "DONE":
print(
f">>>>> Serverless job {serverless_job.job_id}: {serverless_job.status()}"
)
break
else:
break
return
שלב 1: מיפוי קלטים קלאסיים לבעיה קוונטית
1.1: אתחול אובייקט המולקולה באמצעות גיאומטריה מולקולרית ידועה
# Reference guide for building molecule structures:
# https://pyscf.org/user/gto.html
# Video tutorial on building molecular objects in PySCF:
# https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNC2cY9E9j0
molecule_name = "Methylamine"
methylamine_geo = """
N -0.7154 0.0000 0.0000;
C 0.7154 0.0000 0.0000;
H 1.1069 0.0916 1.0174;
H 1.0996 0.8349 -0.5930;
H 1.0996 -0.9274 -0.4345;
H -1.0625 0.8564 0.4294;
H -1.0625 -0.7661 0.5753;
"""
# Imports
import pyscf
from pyscf import gto # Deals with molecular initialization
from pyscf import scf # Solvation methods
# Explicitly defining the Methylamine molecule
mol = gto.M()
mol.atom = methylamine_geo
mol.basis = "cc-pVDZ"
mol.unit = "Ang"
mol.charge = 0
mol.spin = 0
mol.verbose = 0
mol.build()
1.2: הגדרת אפקטי סולבציה באמצעות מודל הרצף המקוטב (Polarizable Continuum Model, PCM)
# You can explore other solvents (such as methanol) by
# retrieving other dielectric parameters from:
# https://gaussian.com/scrf/
from pyscf.solvent import pcm
eps_water = 78.3553 # If solvating in a different medium,
# set this constant appropriately using a known value
cm = pcm.PCM(mol)
cm.eps = eps_water # PySCF defaults to water solvation,
# but here we show this solvation parameter explicitly
cm.method = (
"IEF-PCM" # Alternative solvation models include C-PCM, SS(V)PE, COSMO
)
# Create a "Restricted Hartree-Fock" object for the solute,
# then wrap the SCF object with a Polarizable Continuum Model
mf_pcm0 = scf.RHF(mol).PCM(
cm
) # Restricted Hartree-Fock misses instantaneous correlations,
# post-HF methods like CCSD, CI, MP2 might be worth exploring
1.3: אופטימיזציית גיאומטריה באמצעות TRIC
# Geometry optimization with geomeTRIC
from pyscf.geomopt.geometric_solver import (
optimize,
) # GeomeTRIC under the hood, for geometry optimization
mol_opt = optimize(
mf_pcm0, tol_grad=3e-4, verbose=0
) # Use geomeTRIC/TRIC under the hood
1.4: הכנת מודל הרצף ואובייקט השדה הממוצע (mean field) עם המשתנים הרלוונטיים
from pyscf.mcscf import avas
# Re-define PCM
cm = pcm.PCM(mol_opt)
cm.eps = eps_water # for water
cm.method = "IEF-PCM"
# Re-build Restricted Hartree Fock object
mf_opt = scf.RHF(mol_opt).PCM(cm)
mf_opt.kernel(verbose=0)
# Run AVAS
ao_labels = ["C 2s", "C 2p", "N 2s", "N 2p", "H 1s"]
avas_ = avas.AVAS(
mf_opt, ao_labels, with_iao=True, canonicalize=True, verbose=0
)
avas_.kernel()
norb, ne_act, mo_avas = avas_.ncas, avas_.nelecas, avas_.mo_coeff
num_elec_a = (ne_act + mol_opt.spin) // 2
num_elec_b = (ne_act - mol_opt.spin) // 2
שלב 2: אופטימיזציית הבעיה להרצה על חומרה קוונטית
למידע נוסף על פונקציות העזר המוצגות כאן, ראה את המדריך ליכסון קוונטי מבוסס-דגימה של המילטוניאן כימי.
# Standard SQD helper functions (From SQD Tutorial)
from typing import Sequence
import rustworkx
from qiskit.providers import BackendV2
from qiskit import QuantumCircuit, QuantumRegister
from rustworkx import NoEdgeBetweenNodes, PyGraph
IBM_TWO_Q_GATES = {"cx", "ecr", "cz"}
def create_linear_chains(num_orbitals: int) -> PyGraph:
"""In zig-zag layout, there are two linear chains (with connecting
qubits between the chains). This function creates those two linear
chains: a rustworkx PyGraph with two disconnected linear chains.
Each chain contains `num_orbitals` number of nodes, that is, in the
final graph there are `2 * num_orbitals` number of nodes.
Args:
num_orbitals (int): Number orbitals or nodes in each linear chain.
They are also known as alpha-alpha interaction qubits.
Returns:
A rustworkx.PyGraph with two disconnected linear chains each with
`num_orbitals` number of nodes.
"""
G = rustworkx.PyGraph()
for n in range(num_orbitals):
G.add_node(n)
for n in range(num_orbitals - 1):
G.add_edge(n, n + 1, None)
for n in range(num_orbitals, 2 * num_orbitals):
G.add_node(n)
for n in range(num_orbitals, 2 * num_orbitals - 1):
G.add_edge(n, n + 1, None)
return G
def create_lucj_zigzag_layout(
num_orbitals: int, backend_coupling_graph: PyGraph
) -> tuple[PyGraph, int]:
"""This function creates the complete zigzag graph that 'can be mapped'
to an IBM QPU with heavy-hex connectivity (the zigzag must be an
isomorphic sub-graph to the QPU/backend coupling graph for it to be
mapped). The zigzag pattern includes both linear chains (alpha-alpha
interactions) and connecting qubits between the linear chains
(alpha-beta interactions).
Args:
num_orbitals (int): Number of orbitals, that is, number of nodes in
each alpha-alpha linear chain.
backend_coupling_graph (PyGraph): The coupling graph of the backend
on which the LUCJ ansatz will be mapped and run. This function takes
the coupling graph as a undirected `rustworkx.PyGraph` where there
is only one 'undirected' edge between two nodes, that is, qubits.
Usually, the coupling graph of an IBM backend is directed (for
example, Eagle devices such as ibm_brisbane) or may have two edges
between two nodes (for example, Heron `ibm_torino`). A user
needs to make such graphs undirected or remove duplicate edges
(or do both) to make them compatible with this function.
Returns:
G_new (PyGraph): The graph with IBM backend compliant zigzag pattern.
num_alpha_beta_qubits (int): Number of connecting qubits between the
linear chains in the zigzag pattern. While we want as many
connecting (alpha-beta) qubits between the linear (alpha-alpha)
chains, we cannot accommodate all due to qubit and connectivity
constraints of backends. This is the maximum number of connecting
qubits the zigzag pattern can have while being backend compliant
(that is, isomorphic to backend coupling graph).
"""
isomorphic = False
G = create_linear_chains(num_orbitals=num_orbitals)
num_iters = num_orbitals
while not isomorphic:
G_new = G.copy()
num_alpha_beta_qubits = 0
for n in range(num_iters):
if n % 4 == 0:
new_node = 2 * num_orbitals + num_alpha_beta_qubits
G_new.add_node(new_node)
G_new.add_edge(n, new_node, None)
G_new.add_edge(new_node, n + num_orbitals, None)
num_alpha_beta_qubits = num_alpha_beta_qubits + 1
isomorphic = rustworkx.is_subgraph_isomorphic(
backend_coupling_graph, G_new
)
num_iters -= 1
return G_new, num_alpha_beta_qubits
def lightweight_layout_error_scoring(
backend: BackendV2,
virtual_edges: Sequence[Sequence[int]],
physical_layouts: Sequence[int],
two_q_gate_name: str,
) -> list[list[list[int], float]]:
"""Lightweight and heuristic function to score isomorphic layouts. There
can be many zigzag patterns, each with different set of physical qubits,
that can be mapped to a backend. Some of them might include fewer noise
qubits and couplings than others. This function computes a simple error
score for each such layout. It sums up 2Q gate error for all couplings
in the zigzag pattern (layout) and measurement of errors of physical
qubits in the layout to compute the error score.
Note:
This lightweight scoring can be refined using concepts such as
mapomatic.
Args:
backend (BackendV2): A backend.
virtual_edges (Sequence[Sequence[int]]): Edges in the device-
compliant zigzag pattern where nodes are numbered from 0 to (2 *
num_orbitals + num_alpha_beta_qubits).
physical_layouts (Sequence[int]): All physical layouts of the zigzag
pattern that are isomorphic to each other and to the larger backend
coupling map.
two_q_gate_name (str): The name of the two-qubit gate of the
backend. The name is used for fetching two-qubit gate error from
backend properties.
Returns:
scores (list): A list of lists where each sublist contains two
items. First item is the layout, and second item is a float
representing error score of the layout. The layouts in the `scores`
are sorted in the ascending order of error score.
"""
props = backend.properties()
scores = []
for layout in physical_layouts:
total_2q_error = 0
for edge in virtual_edges:
physical_edge = (layout[edge[0]], layout[edge[1]])
try:
ge = props.gate_error(two_q_gate_name, physical_edge)
except Exception:
ge = props.gate_error(two_q_gate_name, physical_edge[::-1])
total_2q_error += ge
total_measurement_error = 0
for qubit in layout:
meas_error = props.readout_error(qubit)
total_measurement_error += meas_error
scores.append([layout, total_2q_error + total_measurement_error])
return sorted(scores, key=lambda x: x[1])
def _make_backend_cmap_pygraph(backend: BackendV2) -> PyGraph:
graph = backend.coupling_map.graph
if not graph.is_symmetric():
graph.make_symmetric()
backend_coupling_graph = graph.to_undirected()
edge_list = backend_coupling_graph.edge_list()
removed_edge = []
for edge in edge_list:
if set(edge) in removed_edge:
continue
try:
backend_coupling_graph.remove_edge(edge[0], edge[1])
removed_edge.append(set(edge))
except NoEdgeBetweenNodes:
pass
return backend_coupling_graph
def get_zigzag_physical_layout(
num_orbitals: int, backend: BackendV2, score_layouts: bool = True
) -> tuple[list[int], int]:
"""The main function that generates the zigzag pattern
with physical qubits that can be used as an `intial_layout` in a
preset passmanager/transpiler.
Args:
num_orbitals (int): Number of orbitals.
backend (BackendV2): A backend.
score_layouts (bool): Optional. If `True`, it uses the
`lightweight_layout_error_scoring` function to score the
isomorphic layouts and returns the layout with
fewer erroneous qubits.
If `False`, returns the first isomorphic subgraph.
Returns:
A tuple of device compliant layout (list[int]) with zigzag pattern
and an int representing number of alpha-beta-interactions.
"""
backend_coupling_graph = _make_backend_cmap_pygraph(backend=backend)
G, num_alpha_beta_qubits = create_lucj_zigzag_layout(
num_orbitals=num_orbitals,
backend_coupling_graph=backend_coupling_graph,
)
isomorphic_mappings = rustworkx.vf2_mapping(
backend_coupling_graph, G, subgraph=True
)
isomorphic_mappings = list(isomorphic_mappings)
edges = list(G.edge_list())
layouts = []
for mapping in isomorphic_mappings:
initial_layout = [None] * (2 * num_orbitals + num_alpha_beta_qubits)
for key, value in mapping.items():
initial_layout[value] = key
layouts.append(initial_layout)
two_q_gate_name = IBM_TWO_Q_GATES.intersection(
backend.configuration().basis_gates
).pop()
if score_layouts:
scores = lightweight_layout_error_scoring(
backend=backend,
virtual_edges=edges,
physical_layouts=layouts,
two_q_gate_name=two_q_gate_name,
)
return scores[0][0][:-num_alpha_beta_qubits], num_alpha_beta_qubits
return layouts[0][:-num_alpha_beta_qubits], num_alpha_beta_qubits
from qiskit.transpiler import generate_preset_pass_manager
import ffsim
# Initial LUCJ ansatz layout
initial_layout, _ = get_zigzag_physical_layout(norb, backend=backend)
# Initialize a pass manager
pass_manager = generate_preset_pass_manager(
optimization_level=3, backend=backend, initial_layout=initial_layout
)
pass_manager.pre_init = ffsim.qiskit.PRE_INIT
שלבים 3 ו-4: ביצוע באמצעות Qiskit ועיבוד לאחר מכן באמצעות Qiskit Serverless
כאן, אנחנו משלבים את שלב 3 (ביצוע) ושלב 4 (עיבוד לאחר מכן) מכיוון שהקשר היישום של מודל הממס המשתמע דורש לולאת משוב איטרטיבית שמבצעת מספר מחזורים של ביצוע ועיבוד לאחר מכן כדי לשפר את החישוב הסופי.
3.1 חישוב אנרגיית הארטרי-פוק המוגבלת (restricted Hartree-Fock)
# Run the kernel to get the RHF energy
mf_opt = scf.RHF(mol_opt).PCM(cm)
hf_e = float(mf_opt.kernel())
print(f"Restricted Hartree-Fock Energy: {hf_e}")
3.2: קביעת אנרגיית ייחוס קלאסית באמצעות CASCI
# Setup a Serverless Client
worker = client.load("classical_simulation")
from json.encoder import JSONEncoder
ao_labels = ["C 2s", "C 2p", "N 2s", "N 2p", "H 1s"]
data_e = JSONEncoder().encode([mol_opt.tostring(), eps_water, ao_labels])
serverless_job = worker.run(data=data_e)
# Optionally, check the Serverless status feedback
# Don't sit here and stare at the feedback unless debugging.
# You can go develop something else while the Serverless job runs.
_ = feedback_serverless(serverless_job)
# If you make a mistake and need to cancel something
# for job in client.jobs():
# job.cancel()
from json.decoder import JSONDecoder
CASCI_E = JSONDecoder().decode(serverless_job.result()["outputs"])[0]
# We have approximated the red, classical baseline from
# Figure 1 for Methanol (North-West panel)
print(f"CASCI/IEF-PCM(cc-pVDZ): E={CASCI_E}")
הגדרת פרמטרי היישום
# Systematically vary these parameters to improve hardware results
# Set to "True" to run on real hardware
use_hardware = True
# Error suppression/mitigation options
# >> Configure within Sampler primitive
# Transpiler Options
optimization_level = 3
# Heartwood algorithm options
n_iter = 15 # How many update loops to run
resample = 1 # (resample=1 -> resample the QPU after every
# update loop; resample=n_iter -> sample QPU only once)
shots = 10000
# SQD options
energy_tol = 1e-4
occupancies_tol = 1e-3
max_iterations = 12
# Eigenstate solver options
num_batches = 5
samples_per_batch = 300
symmetrize_spin = True
carryover_threshold = 1e-5
max_cycle = 200
# Classical post-processing options
local = (
False # Remote, Serverless (False) versus Local Post-Processing (True)
)
mem = 16 # Memory allocated to each diagonalization worker (Gb)
# Heartwood algorithm subroutines
import numpy as np
import pyscf
from pyscf import ao2mo, cc
from functools import reduce
import ffsim
from json.encoder import JSONEncoder
from json.decoder import JSONDecoder
import time
from functools import partial
from qiskit_addon_sqd.fermion import (
SCIResult,
diagonalize_fermionic_hamiltonian,
solve_sci_batch,
)
def update_rdm(casci_object, dmas):
"""
Inputs:
mc -> CASCI object
dmas -> Spin-summed 1-particle reduced density matrix
This function returns the CASCI/SQD one-body density matrix in
the full basis of atomic orbitals, written as the sum (last line)
of two terms:
- a contribution from the core orbitals,
np.dot(mocore, mocore.conj().T) * 2, (core = inactive and doubly-occupied)
- a contribution from the active-space orbitals and electrons (dmas)
rotated from the active-space to the AO basis (the reduce operation)
Outputs:
rho_approximation: The CASCI/SQD one-body density matrix
in the full basis of atomic orbitals
"""
mo_coeff = casci_object.mo_coeff
ncore = casci_object.ncore
ncas = casci_object.ncas
mocore = mo_coeff[:, :ncore]
mocas = mo_coeff[:, ncore : ncore + ncas]
dm1 = np.dot(mocore, mocore.conj().T) * 2
rho_approximation = dm1 + reduce(np.dot, (mocas, dmas, mocas.conj().T))
return rho_approximation
def run_active_space_calculation(
h1e_cas, h2e_cas, norb, ne_act, orbs, fermilevel, ecore
):
# ----- perform an HF and a CCSD calculation in the active space
from pyscf import tools
from datetime import datetime
now = datetime.now().strftime("%H:%M:%S")
print(">>>>> ACTIVE SPACE CALCULATIONS ")
tools.fcidump.from_integrals(
f"as_fcidump_{now}.txt",
h1e_cas,
h2e_cas,
norb,
ne_act,
ms=0,
nuc=ecore,
) # Forcefully represents the active space in the correct structure
mf_as = tools.fcidump.to_scf(f"as_fcidump_{now}.txt")
os.remove(f"as_fcidump_{now}.txt")
mf_as.kernel()
print(">>>>> RUNNING CCSD")
mf_cc = cc.CCSD(mf_as)
mf_cc.kernel()
orbts = mf_as.mo_coeff
t1, t2 = mf_cc.t1, mf_cc.t2
print(">>>>> UPDATED t1, t2 PARAMETERS")
# ----- update the HF orbitals
active = list(
range(fermilevel - ne_act // 2, fermilevel - ne_act // 2 + norb)
)
orbs[:, active] = np.dot(orbs[:, active], orbts)
return orbs, t1, t2
def get_lucj(norb, num_elec_a, num_elec_b, t1, t2, n_reps=1):
print(">>>>> CONSTRUCTING LUCJ CIRCUIT")
alpha_alpha_indices = [(p, p + 1) for p in range(norb - 1)]
alpha_beta_indices = [(p, p) for p in range(0, norb, 4)]
ucj_op = ffsim.UCJOpSpinBalanced.from_t_amplitudes(
t1=t1, # <---- Update t1 each loop
t2=t2, # <---- Update t2 each loop
n_reps=n_reps,
interaction_pairs=(alpha_alpha_indices, alpha_beta_indices),
)
nelec = (num_elec_a, num_elec_b)
# create an empty quantum circuit
qubits = QuantumRegister(2 * norb, name="q")
circuit = QuantumCircuit(qubits)
# prepare Hartree-Fock state as the reference state
# and append it to the quantum circuit
circuit.append(ffsim.qiskit.PrepareHartreeFockJW(norb, nelec), qubits)
# apply the UCJ operator to the reference state
circuit.append(ffsim.qiskit.UCJOpSpinBalancedJW(ucj_op), qubits)
circuit.measure_all()
return circuit
# Classical diagonalization engine sent to HPC
def classically_diagonalize(
bit_array=None, # Bit string array (only needed if locally processing data)
nuclear_repulsion_energy=None, # Electronic energy from the core orbitals
hcore=None, # 1-electron hamiltonian integrals
eri=None, # 2-electron hamiltonian integrals
num_orbitals=None, # Number of spatial orbitals
nelec=None, # Number of electrons
num_elec_a=None, # Alpha orbitals
num_elec_b=None, # Beta orbitals
job_id=None, # QPU bitstring Job ID
client=None, # Diagonalization engine worker
energy_tol=1e-4, # SQD option
occupancies_tol=1e-3, # SQD option
max_iterations=12, # SQD option
num_batches=8, # Eigenstate solver option
samples_per_batch=300, # Eigenstate solver option
symmetrize_spin=False, # Eigenstate solver option
carryover_threshold=1e-5, # Eigenstate solver option
max_cycle=200, # Eigenstate solver option
local=True, # Remote vs Local Diagonalization
mem=16.0, # Memory per Serverless Worker (Gb)
):
print(">>>>> STARTING DIAGONALIZATION ENGINE ")
# Pass options to the built-in eigensolver. If you just want to use
# the defaults, you can omit this step, in which case you would not
# specify the sci_solver argument in the call to
# diagonalize_fermionic_hamiltonian below.
if local:
sci_solver = partial(
solve_sci_batch, spin_sq=0.0, max_cycle=max_cycle
)
# List to capture intermediate results
result_history = []
def callback(results: list[SCIResult]):
result_history.append(results)
iteration = len(result_history)
print(f">>>>> SQD ITERATION {iteration}")
for i, result in enumerate(results):
print(f">>>>> SUBSAMPLE {i}")
print(
f">>>>> \tENERGY: {result.energy + nuclear_repulsion_energy}"
)
print(
f">>>>> \tSUBSPACE DIMENSION: {np.prod(result.sci_state.amplitudes.shape)}"
)
result = diagonalize_fermionic_hamiltonian(
hcore,
eri,
bit_array,
samples_per_batch=samples_per_batch,
norb=num_orbitals,
nelec=(nelec // 2, nelec // 2),
num_batches=num_batches,
energy_tol=energy_tol,
occupancies_tol=occupancies_tol,
max_iterations=max_iterations,
sci_solver=sci_solver,
symmetrize_spin=symmetrize_spin,
carryover_threshold=carryover_threshold,
callback=callback,
seed=12345,
)
result = (result.energy, result.rdm1, result.rdm2)
else:
# Serverless Logic
print(
f">>>>> SENDING QISKIT RUNTIME JOB {job_id} TO QISKIT SERVERLESS"
)
data = [
job_id,
hcore.tolist(),
eri.tolist(),
int(num_orbitals),
float(nuclear_repulsion_energy),
int(num_elec_a),
int(num_elec_b),
]
# Encode the execution dependencies with the JSONEncoder
data_e = JSONEncoder().encode(data)
# Send to Serverless
worker = client.load("diagonalization_engine")
serverless_job = worker.run(
data=data_e,
energy_tol=energy_tol, # SQD option
occupancies_tol=occupancies_tol, # SQD option
max_iterations=max_iterations, # SQD option
symmetrize_spin=symmetrize_spin, # Eigenstate solver option
carryover_threshold=carryover_threshold, # Eigenstate solver option
num_batches=num_batches, # Eigenstate solver option
samples_per_batch=samples_per_batch, # Eigenstate solver option
max_cycle=max_cycle, # Eigenstate solver option
mem=mem, # Memory per Worker (Gb)
)
# Wait for the job to execute
_ = feedback_serverless(serverless_job)
o_data = JSONDecoder().decode(serverless_job.result()["outputs"])
result = (o_data[1], np.array(o_data[2]), np.array(o_data[3]))
print(f">>>>>>>>>> Active Space Energy: {o_data[1]}")
print(f">>>>>>>>>> rdm1: {o_data[2]}")
print(f">>>>>>>>>> rdm2: {o_data[3]}")
return result
# The Heartwood algorithm
import numpy as np
from qiskit_ibm_runtime import SamplerV2 as Sampler
from qiskit_addon_sqd.counts import generate_bit_array_uniform
mc = pyscf.mcscf.CASCI(mf_opt, ncas=norb, nelecas=ne_act).PCM(cm)
mc.with_solvent.method = mf_opt.with_solvent.method # Here we make sure
# that mc is also using the same solvent method defined earlier (IEF-PCM)
mc.with_solvent.eps = mf_opt.with_solvent.eps # Set the dielectric parameters
mc.mo_coeff = mo_avas.copy() # Update the molecular orbitals to include
# those computed in the presence of the solvent
h1e_cas, ecore = (
mc.get_h1eff()
) # <-- h1eff is the 1-electron hamiltonian integrals. h1e_cas is
# a common alias. ecore is the electronic energy from the core orbitals.
h2e_cas = ao2mo.restore(
1, mc.get_h2eff(), norb
) # <-- get the 2-electron hamiltonian integrals
mc.mo_coeff, t1, t2 = run_active_space_calculation(
h1e_cas,
h2e_cas,
norb,
ne_act,
mo_avas.copy(),
mf_opt.mol.nelectron // 2,
ecore,
)
# Sampler primitive options
sampler = Sampler(mode=backend)
# Explore error suppression techniques and see if they can improve result quality
sampler.options.dynamical_decoupling.enable = True
sampler.options.dynamical_decoupling.sequence_type = "XY4"
sampler.options.twirling.enable_measure = True
sampler.options.environment.job_tags = ["TUT_ISC"]
# sampler.options.twirling.enable_gates = False
# sampler.options.twirling.num_randomizations = 10
# sampler.options.twirling.shots_per_randomization = 1024
# initial approximation for rdm1
with_solvent_e, with_solvent_v = None, None # Don't touch
data = []
for iiter in range(n_iter):
print(f">>>>> IMPLICIT SOLVENT ITERATION {iiter+1}/{n_iter}")
if with_solvent_v is not None:
# Subsequent update loops enter here
mc.get_hcore = lambda *args: mc._scf.get_hcore() + with_solvent_v
else:
# First update loop starts here
# hcore is the CAS space (classically computed) 1-electron
# hamiltonian, which we default to at the start of the routine.
mc.get_hcore = (
lambda *args: mc._scf.get_hcore()
) # REF: https://pyscf.org/pyscf_api_docs/pyscf.mcscf.html#pyscf.scf.hf.CASBase.get_h1cas
# Alias mapping
# hcore : h1e_cas : h1e_eff
# nuclear_repulsion_energy : ecore
# eri : h2e_cas : h2e_eff
h1e_cas, ecore = (
mc.get_h1eff()
) # <-- h1eff is the 1-electron hamiltonian integrals. h1e_cas is a
# common alias. ecore is the electronic energy from the core orbitals.
h2e_cas = ao2mo.restore(
1, mc.get_h2eff(), norb
) # <-- get the 2-electron hamiltonian integrals
mc.mo_coeff, t1, t2 = run_active_space_calculation(
h1e_cas,
h2e_cas,
norb,
ne_act,
mo_avas.copy(),
mf_opt.mol.nelectron // 2,
ecore,
)
if use_hardware:
if (
iiter % resample == 0
): # <-- Toggle how often you refresh your bitstrings here. The
# developer suggests that you do it every time, but benevolently
# provides the freedom to disagree with him via the resample
# control variable.
# The "Quantum-Centric" part
print(">>>>> GENERATING BITSTRINGS USING QUANTUM HARDWARE")
# LUCJ Ansatz construction
circuit = get_lucj(norb, num_elec_a, num_elec_b, t1, t2, n_reps=1)
print(f">>>>> TRANSPILING LUCJ TO {backend.name}")
isa_circuit = pass_manager.run(circuit)
print(f">>>>> SUBMITTING ISA_CIRCUIT TO {backend.name}")
job = sampler.run(
[isa_circuit], shots=shots
) # <----- Error Suppression/Mitigation configured performed upstream
job_id = str(job.job_id())
timer = 0
while job.status() != "DONE":
timer += 10
print(
f">>>>> [{timer}s] RUNTIME JOB {job_id}: {job.status()}"
)
time.sleep(10)
primitive_result = job.result()
print(f">>>>> RETRIEVED {job_id} FROM {backend.name}")
pub_result = primitive_result[0]
bit_array = pub_result.data.meas
else:
print(">>>>> GENERATING BITSTRINGS CLASSICALLY")
rng = np.random.default_rng(24)
bit_array = generate_bit_array_uniform(
100_000, 2 * norb, rand_seed=rng
) # <-- Sample bitstrings from a uniform distribution. This is
# useful for debug, but runs out of steam on large systems
job_id = float(
"nan"
) # <-- we will check that valid job_id's were passed during grading
local = True
# The "Classical Post-processing" part
result = classically_diagonalize(
bit_array=bit_array,
nuclear_repulsion_energy=ecore, # Electronic energy from the core orbitals
hcore=h1e_cas, # 1-electron hamiltonian integrals
eri=h2e_cas, # 2-electron hamiltonian integrals
num_orbitals=norb, # Number of spatial orbitals
nelec=ne_act, # Number of electrons
num_elec_a=ne_act // 2, # Alpha orbitals
num_elec_b=ne_act // 2, # Beta orbitals
job_id=job_id, # QPU bitstring Job ID
client=client, # Diagonalization engine worker
energy_tol=energy_tol, # SQD option
occupancies_tol=occupancies_tol, # SQD option
max_iterations=max_iterations, # SQD option
num_batches=num_batches, # Eigenstate solver option
samples_per_batch=samples_per_batch, # Eigenstate solver option
symmetrize_spin=symmetrize_spin, # Eigenstate solver option
carryover_threshold=carryover_threshold, # Eigenstate solver option
max_cycle=max_cycle, # Eigenstate solver option
local=local, # Remote vs Local Diagonalization
mem=mem, # Memory per Worker (Gb)
)
# e : SQD-based estimate of the energy
# rdm1: Spin-summed 1-particle reduced density matrix
e, rdm1 = result[0], result[1]
rho_approximation = update_rdm(
mc, rdm1
).copy() # <--- Reconstruct the one-body density matrix in the
# atomic orbital basis to update the external potential due to
# the solvent
if with_solvent_e is not None:
# Subsequent update loops enter here
edup = np.einsum(
"ij,ji->", with_solvent_v, rho_approximation
) # <-- edup: Incrementing the energy calculation with
# subsequent iterations
e += ecore + with_solvent_e - edup
else:
# First update loop enters here
e += (
ecore # Pulled from the CAS space object (molecule's core energy)
)
# Outputs:
# with_solvent_e : scalar energy correction due to solvent polarization
# with_solvent_v : Fock-like matrix to be added to the core Hamiltonian in SCF
with_solvent_e, with_solvent_v = mc.with_solvent._get_vind(
rho_approximation
)
data.append((iiter, float(e), job_id))
print(f">>>>> END IITER {iiter}")
print(f">>>>> TOTAL ENERGY: {e}\n")
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
from matplotlib.ticker import ScalarFormatter
def plot_data(data, baseline=0, name=None, save=False):
x_vals, y_vals, job_ids = zip(*data)
fig, ax = plt.subplots(figsize=(10, 6))
# Plot line + markers
ax.plot(
x_vals,
y_vals,
color="navy",
linewidth=2,
marker="o",
markersize=5,
label="Energy trajectory",
)
ax.axhline(
baseline,
color="red",
linestyle="--",
linewidth=1.5,
label="Reference energy",
)
# Force plain formatting
ax.yaxis.set_major_formatter(ScalarFormatter(useMathText=True))
ax.ticklabel_format(style="plain", axis="y")
# Annotate each point with its exact value
for x, y, job_id in zip(x_vals, y_vals, job_ids):
ax.annotate(
f"{y:.8f}, ID: {job_id}",
(x, y),
textcoords="offset points",
xytext=(0, 8), # vertical offset
ha="center",
fontsize=8,
rotation=25,
color="navy",
)
# Annotate the Classical Reference line
for x, y in zip([0.5], [baseline]):
ax.annotate(
f"{y:.5f}",
(x, y),
textcoords="offset points",
xytext=(0, 8), # vertical offset
ha="center",
fontsize=8,
rotation=25,
color="red",
)
# Titles, labels, etc
ax.set_title(
f"SQD/IEF-PCM(cc-pVDZ) - {name}\nEnergy Convergence",
fontsize=14,
fontweight="bold",
pad=15,
)
ax.set_xlabel("Update Iterations", fontsize=12)
ax.set_ylabel("Total Energy (Hartrees)", fontsize=12)
ax.grid(True, linestyle="--", linewidth=0.6, alpha=0.7)
ax.legend(frameon=True, loc="best")
plt.tight_layout()
if save:
plt.savefig(f"./results/{name}_energy_convergence.png")
return fig, ax
# Plot your data
fig, ax = plot_data(data, baseline=CASCI_E, name=molecule_name, save=True)
plt.show()
צעדים הבאים
המלצות
אם מצאת את העבודה הזו מעניינת, ייתכן שיעניינו אותך המשאבים הבאים:
-
ה-Quantum Resource Management Interface (QRMI) — משלב משאבים קוונטיים וקלאסיים לתוך מנהלי עומסי עבודה של HPC כמו Slurm, ומרחיב את דפוס המחשוב המבוזר שהודגם במדריך זה
-
פרוס והרץ תבנית לסימולציית מבנה אלקטרוני עם מודל ממס משתמע (תבנית Qiskit Function של SQD IEF-PCM, שפותחה במשותף על ידי מרפאת קליבלנד ו-IBM)